Kimora Lee Simmons’s New Reality Show Draws Criticism Over Weight-Related Dialogue
LOS ANGELES, Calif. — Kimora Lee Simmons returned to reality television this December with her family series Kimora: Back in the Fab Lane on E!, but the show quickly ignited controversy following a contentious exchange about weight in its third episode. The dialogue between Simmons’s daughters, Aoki Lee Simmons and Ming Lee Simmons, has been widely criticized as “triggering” and emblematic of problematic attitudes toward body image and health.
In the scene, 25-year-old Ming compliments her 23-year-old sister Aoki by saying she looks “healthy,” a comment that Aoki immediately rebuffs with visible offense. The sisters’ back-and-forth escalates as Aoki accuses Ming of implying she is “fat,” while Ming insists she meant “refreshed.” Their mother, Kimora Lee Simmons, then interjects with a remark about Aoki’s ability to “last a winter,” which Aoki ironically thanks her for, further complicating the emotional tone.
The exchange has sparked significant online backlash, with many viewers expressing discomfort and concern over the portrayal of weight and health on the show. Critics have lamented the resurgence of late 1990s and early 2000s diet culture tropes, which often equated thinness with worth and health — a perspective widely challenged by contemporary health experts.
Aoki Lee Simmons has been open about her struggles with disordered eating, previously sharing that she lost weight after being told she wasn’t “skinny enough” for modeling opportunities at Paris Fashion Week. Her vulnerability adds weight to the controversy, with many viewers finding the televised argument particularly distressing given her history.
Experts and advocacy organizations emphasize the importance of sensitive and informed conversations about body image. The National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA) offers resources and support for individuals affected by eating disorders and highlights the potential harm of triggering media portrayals. For immediate help, individuals can call the NEDA helpline at 1-800-931-2237 or text “NEDA” to 741741 for 24/7 crisis support.
Public response on social media platforms like X (formerly Twitter) has been largely critical, with users calling for networks to reconsider airing such content. “This level of insecurity in this young girl is so devastating to watch,” one user wrote, while another commented, “I hate that the awful late 90s/00s diet culture is back with a vengeance.” Others questioned the role of Kimora Lee Simmons herself in reinforcing harmful beauty standards through her remarks.
The controversy underscores ongoing societal challenges in addressing weight, health, and body positivity in media. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), promoting healthy behaviors without stigmatizing weight is critical to public health efforts. Media portrayals that inadvertently perpetuate negative stereotypes can undermine these goals.
As conversations about representation and mental health continue to evolve, this incident serves as a reminder of the responsibility entertainment platforms have in shaping narratives around sensitive topics. Viewers and advocates alike urge a more compassionate and nuanced approach to discussions about body image, especially when involving individuals with known vulnerabilities.
More broadly, the episode has reignited debates about the impact of reality television on viewers’ perceptions of self-worth and health. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and other agencies encourage media literacy and critical engagement with content that addresses appearance and wellness.
As the series continues, it remains to be seen how the Simmons family and E! network will respond to the criticism and whether future episodes will address the concerns raised by audiences and health professionals alike.
Leave a Reply