Critics Highlight 15 TV Characters with Notably Poor Story Arcs

NEW YORK — November 21, 2025 — A recent analysis of television characters has identified 15 figures whose story arcs have been widely regarded as among the weakest in recent TV history. The review, which covers a range of genres and series, notes that while some character declines were anticipated, others took viewers by surprise.

Among the characters discussed, Criston Cole from the series “House of the Dragon” stands out as having one of the most abrupt and polarizing narrative shifts. According to critics, no other character has elicited such a swift reversal in audience perception as Cole, whose development diverged sharply from early expectations.

The assessment highlights how character arcs can significantly impact viewers’ engagement with a series. Some arcs were criticized for feeling unearned or inconsistent with previously established traits, while others were seen as natural evolutions that nonetheless disappointed fans.

The list includes characters from a variety of shows, reflecting a broad spectrum of storytelling approaches. Some arcs were described as deservedly negative, aligning with the characters’ flawed natures or narrative roles. Others, however, were unexpected, leaving audiences questioning the creative decisions behind their transformations.

Television critics emphasize that character development remains a crucial element of successful storytelling. When handled well, it can deepen the narrative and enrich the viewing experience. Conversely, poorly executed arcs risk alienating audiences and diminishing a show’s overall impact.

While the review does not provide an exhaustive ranking, it serves as a commentary on the challenges writers face in maintaining coherent and satisfying character trajectories over multiple seasons. It also reflects the evolving expectations of viewers who increasingly scrutinize character consistency and growth.

The discussion around these 15 characters underscores the importance of narrative cohesion and thoughtful character design in contemporary television. As series continue to push creative boundaries, the balance between surprising developments and believable progression remains a key consideration for showrunners and writers.

This analysis contributes to ongoing conversations about storytelling quality in television, offering insight into why certain characters resonate or falter in the eyes of audiences and critics alike.