Paul Finebaum Criticizes Stephen A. Smith’s Comments on Ole Miss Coaching Situation

NEW ORLEANS, La. — November 21, 2025 — Paul Finebaum has publicly challenged Stephen A. Smith’s recent remarks suggesting that race could play a role in the future coaching decisions at the University of Mississippi. The exchange unfolded following Smith’s commentary on ESPN’s “First Take,” where he linked the potential vacancy of Ole Miss’s head football coaching position to racial considerations.

Smith’s comments sparked immediate reactions, with Finebaum, a longtime college football analyst familiar with Southeastern Conference dynamics, pushing back against the notion that race should be a defining factor in the hiring process. According to sources familiar with the discussion, Finebaum emphasized that coaching decisions at Ole Miss should be based on merit and performance rather than racial identity.

The controversy centers on Lane Kiffin’s uncertain status as Ole Miss head coach. Kiffin’s tenure has been under scrutiny due to mixed team performance and speculation about his future with the program. Smith suggested on “First Take” that if the position were to open, race might influence the selection process, a comment that Finebaum found problematic.

Finebaum’s response, delivered through various media outlets, underscored his belief that framing the coaching vacancy in racial terms detracts from the primary considerations of coaching ability and fit within the program’s culture. He argued that such discussions risk overshadowing the qualifications and accomplishments of candidates, regardless of their background.

The debate highlights broader conversations within college sports about diversity and inclusion, especially in high-profile coaching roles. While many advocate for increased representation of minority coaches, others caution against allowing race to overshadow other critical factors in hiring decisions.

Ole Miss has not made any official statements regarding the coaching position or the ongoing commentary. The university’s athletic department continues to evaluate the football program’s direction amid the current season’s challenges.

The exchange between Finebaum and Smith reflects the complexities surrounding race and leadership roles in college athletics, a topic that remains sensitive and multifaceted. Both commentators are influential voices in sports media, and their differing views on this issue have generated significant discussion among fans and analysts alike.

As the Ole Miss football program approaches the end of its season, attention will remain on whether Kiffin retains his role or if the university opts for a new direction. The conversation sparked by Smith and Finebaum adds a layer of scrutiny to what is already a closely watched coaching situation in the Southeastern Conference.