Grandmother Challenges Insanity Defense as Mother Accused of Killing Daughter Appears in Court
LOMPOC, Calif. — Ashlee Buzzard, the mother charged with the first-degree murder of her 9-year-old daughter Melodee Buzzard, appeared in Santa Barbara County Superior Court this week to set a date for her preliminary hearing. The case has sent shockwaves through the community and left family members struggling to reconcile the woman they once knew with the accused killer.
Melodee was reported missing in October after embarking on a road trip with her mother from California. Nearly two months later, on December 6, authorities discovered Melodee’s body in a remote area of Wayne County, Utah. The child had suffered fatal gunshot wounds to the head. Prosecutors have charged Ashlee Buzzard with first-degree murder and filed sentencing enhancements alleging the use of a firearm during the felony and murder while lying in wait. Buzzard was arrested on December 23 and arraigned three days later. She has pleaded not guilty and is being held without bail, with a preliminary hearing scheduled for January 21 in Lompoc.
Outside the courthouse, Melodee’s paternal grandmother, Lilly Denes, spoke candidly about the case, expressing disbelief and sorrow. “When I met her nine or 10 years ago, she was not like this. I don’t know what happened,” Denes said, referring to Ashlee Buzzard. She recalled the first time her son, Rubiell Meza, brought Buzzard home. “She was really quiet and just looking at me from head to toe,” Denes said. “I told my son, ‘Mijo, is this lady, is this girl OK? … She’s just staring.’” Meza, who tragically died in a motorcycle accident while Melodee was still an infant, dismissed Denes’s concerns, explaining that Buzzard was simply shy.
Denes vehemently rejected any suggestion that Buzzard might mount an insanity defense. “She planned everything,” Denes told reporters, emphasizing that the killing was deliberate. The grandmother’s remarks come amid growing public interest in the case and questions about what led to the tragic death of the young girl.
Authorities have detailed a cross-country trip during which Buzzard allegedly attempted to avoid detection, culminating in the tragic discovery of Melodee’s body in Utah. The Santa Barbara County District Attorney’s Office announced it would seek a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole rather than the death penalty.
The case has drawn attention from multiple law enforcement agencies, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which executed search warrants and assisted in the investigation. The complexity of the case, involving interstate travel and attempts to evade authorities, has underscored the challenges prosecutors face.
Melodee’s disappearance and death have also highlighted the importance of child protection protocols and the ongoing efforts of agencies such as the Children’s Bureau to safeguard vulnerable children. The tragic outcome serves as a somber reminder of the need for vigilance and support for at-risk youth.
As the legal proceedings continue, the family remains in mourning. Denes recalled the family’s embrace of Melodee in her early years, including a large baby shower that brought relatives together in celebration. “All my family came,” Denes said, “That can tell you how much she was loved.”
The preliminary hearing will offer the first formal opportunity for the court to review evidence and determine whether the case should proceed to trial. Meanwhile, the community watches closely, grappling with the heartbreaking loss and the complex questions surrounding the accused mother’s actions.
For updates on court proceedings and child protection resources, the public can refer to the California Courts website and the Administration for Children and Families. The case remains a poignant example of the intersection between family tragedy and the justice system.
Leave a Reply